Review · Journal of Educational Science and Technology · April 30, 2025
Teachers’ Digital Literacy Communication Competence: A Meta-Analysis
Begimbetova Guldana Atymtaevna, Heri Retnawati, M.Bruri Triyono, Gulzhaina K. Kassymova, Kistantia Elok Mumpuni
Abstract
This research aims to synthesize empirical findings on high school teachers' digital communication competence through a meta-analytic approach, addressing inconsistencies in existing literature and the urgent need to enhance educators' digital literacy. The study investigates the conclusions of 42 articles published between 2008 and 2022, focusing on the theme of digital communication competence. A systematic review was conducted using the PRISMA framework, involving a three-stage process of identification, screening, and inclusion of relevant studies. The analysis revealed a common true effect size across all studies, but significant variability in effect sizes, with a variance (τ²) of 421.92 and a standard deviation (τ) of 20.5408. The Q-Profile indicated substantial heterogeneity (Q=6090163.73, p=0, I²=100%), highlighting inconsistencies in the conclusions drawn from the pooled articles. Additionally, the funnel plot analysis showed skewness, indicating potential publication bias. These findings underscore the need for further research to explore the interaction between pedagogical and technological knowledge, ultimately aiming to improve digital communication competence among high school teachers. The study concludes that addressing these inconsistencies is crucial for developing effective strategies to enhance educators' digital literacy in an increasingly digital educational landscape.
More by Guldana Begimbetova
- Supporting data for "Culture-Based Learning in Primary Education: A Systematic Literature Review of Students' Creative Thinking Development"Zenodo · 2026
- Meta-Analysis of EMI in Kazakhstani Secondary Education: A Case of “Bilim-Innovation” LyceumsMultidisciplinary Journal of Thought and Research · 2026 · Citations: 8
- Mapping Quality Gaps of Islamic and Non-Islamic Kindergarten: A Systematic Literature ReviewUlumuddin Jurnal Ilmu-ilmu Keislaman · 2026
- A Cognitive Measurement Model for Pre-Service Teachers’ Higher Order of Thinking Skills in Digital Literacy.ePrints - UNY · 2026
