Review · Ulumuddin Jurnal Ilmu-ilmu Keislaman · March 12, 2026
Mapping Quality Gaps of Islamic and Non-Islamic Kindergarten: A Systematic Literature Review
Agung Prihantoro, Oscar Ndayizeye, Begimbetova Guldana Atymtaevna
Abstract
Quality of Islamic and Non-Islamic kindergarten is a serious problem to solve immediately. But no research is done on mapping quality gaps of kindergarten in the world. This research mapped quality gaps of kindergarten in the whole world. Research method is systematic literature review. Results of the research reveals that quality gaps of kindergarten were mapped into seven categories. They are (1) learning opportunity, (2) accreditation instrument, (3) graduate competence, (4) learning process, (5) teacher and education personnel, (6) facilities, (7) parent involvement. There is no different categories among Islamic and non-Islamic kindergartens. These gaps spread around the world in America, Asia and Europe continents. No article presents the gaps in Africa and Australia continents and it bears little big questions.
More by Guldana Begimbetova
- Supporting data for "Culture-Based Learning in Primary Education: A Systematic Literature Review of Students' Creative Thinking Development"Zenodo · 2026
- Meta-Analysis of EMI in Kazakhstani Secondary Education: A Case of “Bilim-Innovation” LyceumsMultidisciplinary Journal of Thought and Research · 2026 · Citations: 8
- A Cognitive Measurement Model for Pre-Service Teachers’ Higher Order of Thinking Skills in Digital Literacy.ePrints - UNY · 2026
- Bridging the gap across global research on numeracy assessment in the digital era: Toward the development of diagnostic assessmentSpringer Link · 2025