The Phenomenon of «Russian Toska» and Existential Angst: A Comparative Analysis of Conceptualizations

Abstract

The article presents a comparative analysis of the phenomenon of Russian «toska» and Western existential fear (Angst), conducted in the context of two conceptual spheres. The motivation for this analysis is driven by the relevance of the situation of interaction between European and traditional Russian worldview paradigms. Philosophical interpretations of melancholy by Russian thinkers such as N.A. Berdyaev, I.A. Ilyin, S.G. Lishaev, and others are considered, as well as corresponding analyses of Angst in the Western philosophical tradition, presented by S. Kierkegaard, M. Heidegger, J.-P. Sartre, and others. It is shown that both phenomena are diffuse and amorphous, related to the experience of «nothingness.» However, they differ in their semantic orientation: Russian melancholy is oriented towards the transcendent, while Western existential fear (Angst) is directed towards the awareness of existential nothingness. In conclusion, it is argued that despite their common existential nature, these states are determined by the historical and cultural context and act as catalysts for expanding consciousness and achieving authentic existence.

Related publications

• Modeling public opinion formation processes using multi-agent AI systems: practical experienceTHE KAZAN SOCIALLY-HUMANITARIAN BULLETIN · 2026 · Same author: Максим Горшенин
• Symbolic nature of practices of appropriation of urban space as a form of civic activismRevista Gestão & Tecnologia · 2023 · Citations: 1 · Same author: Максим Горшенин
• Cross-Modal Modeling of Emotional and Thematic Trajectories in Holocaust Survivor Oral HistoriesProceedings of the Language Resources and Evaluation Conference · 2026 · Shared topic: History of Emotions Research