Article · Frontiers in Education · December 8, 2025
Guiding the uncharted: the emerging (and missing) policies on Generative AI in higher education
Meruyert Aristombayeva, Ryskhan Satybaldiyeva, Barani Maung Maung, Dongwon Lee
Abstract
Soon AI may move beyond its role as a mere tool to funcBon as a creaBve agent-potenBally even as a virtual student or professor-capable of generaBng original artworks and contribuBng to research leadership. However, it remains unclear whether educaBonal insBtuBons are adequately prepared for such a rapid integraBon of AI into the educaBonal and research processes. This quesBon becomes parBcularly relevant in the context of rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) and generaBve arBficial intelligence (GenAI) and their potenBal to transform both the landscape of scienBfic research and educaBonal methodologies. This work therefore examines how educaBonal insBtuBons are responding to the integraBon of AI into research and educaBon. Specifically, we analyzed policies and guidelines regulaBng the use of GenAI in both general universiBes and art-focused insBtuBons, and conducted a strategic review of insBtuBonal approaches, along with a content analysis of some curricula related to GenAI implementaBon. Based on the analysis, we posit that current GenAI policies in higher educaBon are largely reacBve, unevenly implemented across regions and disciplines, and oWen fail to address research-specific use cases and the disBnct challenges faced by art-focused insBtuBons. This finding aligns with recent work showing that insBtuBons tend to conform to external regulatory, normaBve, and mimeBc pressures in their adopBon of GenAI, oWen prioriBzing legiBmacy and compliance over proacBve strategic vision [14]. From an educaBonal perspecBve, researcher further argue that Bloom's Taxonomy requires revision to address the cogniBve, affecBve, and metacogniBve demands of AI-assisted learning, underscoring the need for insBtuBonal policies that not only regulate GenAI but also foster criBcal thinking, ethical reasoning, and iteraBve learning processes in higher educaBon [15].UniversiBes worldwide face the dual nature of using these technologies [5,6], navigaBng the potenBal for innovaBon alongside the need to address ethical and pracBcal concerns [2] that may disproporBonately affect students and faculty [8]. Notably, current guidelines for the use of GenAI in higher educaBon tend to represent a reacBve response, oWen embedded within modern technology programs. The discourse surrounding GenAI in higher educaBon is mulBfaceted, encompassing discussions on academic integrity, innovaBve teaching programs, and the potenBal for GenAI to enhance student outcomes [2,3]. With the release of ChatGPT, these issues have gained a parBcular relevance. While many universiBes have experienced challenges associated with plagiarism, data confidenBality and privacy [1,2,10], art-focused universiBes have encountered issues related to copyright protecBon and assessment of the originality of creaBvity [4].In this paper, we comprehensively reviewed publicly available policies and guidelines regarding the use of GenAI in educaBon and research from higher educaBon insBtuBons in the US, Europe and Central Asia. General universiBes from the US and Europe were selected from among the leaders of the QS World University Rankings 2024. For the US, we focused on the top 20 universiBes according to the QS World University Rankings 2024 (general category). The list of European universiBes was compiled with explicit consideraBon for geographical diversity, ensuring representaBon from different European countries. StarBng from the top of the QS rankings, we applied an addiBonal rule: if several consecuBve insBtuBons belonged to the same country (e.g., mulBple from the UK), we selected the highest-ranked one and then moved to the next university from another European country. This procedure helped avoid overrepresentaBon of a single country while sBll capturing leading insBtuBons. If a university appeared in the ranking but did not provide publicly available GenAI-related policies or guidelines (i.e., official documents explicitly outlining recommendaBons or regulaBons), it was excluded from the sample. In such cases, we conBnued down the QS list unBl a suitable insBtuBon was idenBfied. References to projects, pilot iniBaBves, or informal menBons of GenAI were not considered sufficient for inclusion. It is important to note that although many insBtuBons arBculate strategies (e.g., vision statements, curricular integraBon plans), these do not always translate into concrete policies (e.g., official guidelines for faculty and students). Throughout the analysis we therefore treat strategies as indicaBve of insBtuBonal intent, while policies are considered evidence of operaBonalized regulaBon.The list of art universiBes was compiled based on the QS World University Rankings by Subject (Art & Design), but not many relevant policies were publicly available on the universiBes' websites. We searched for exisBng policies and guidelines using the following keywords on Google: "GeneraBve AI Policy in art universiBes USA", "GeneraBve AI Policy in art universiBes Europe [countries]", "GeneraBve AI Policy in higher educaBon".UniversiBes in Central Asia were selected based on the QS World University Rankings by Region: Central Asia 2024, with consideraBon given to insBtuBons from all five Central Asian countries. Since many universiBes in the region from the list did not have policies or guidelines available on their official websites, we conducted addiBonal searches using Google. In our search, we used keywords in both English and Russian, such as "Policy on the use of generaBve AI in Kazakhstan", "Satbayev University GeneraBve AI Guide", as well as similar formulaBons for each university and country in the region. To idenBfy art universiBes in Central Asia, we conducted a separate search using keywords such as "Art UniversiBes in Kazakhstan" and equivalent terms for other countries in the region.Figure 1 illustrates the selecBon of policies and guidelines from general and art universiBes in the US, Europe and Central Asia for this study. The analyzed documents provide informaBon on exisBng policies and guidelines for students, teaching staff, and researchers regarding the safe and ethical use of generaBve AI in teaching and research. The analysis demonstrates that many general universiBes in the USA and Europe have developed their own policies and guidelines; however, policies regulaBng the use of generaBve AI are less developed in art-focused universiBes. Policies addressing students and faculty are more prevalent than those for researchers, however, 40% of the analyzed universiBes have separate guidelines for researchers with detailed recommendaBons. In Central Asia universiBes, there is a notable absence of policies and guidelines regulaBng the use of GenAI. Only a few general universiBes, including Nazarbayev University in Kazakhstan and Westminster InternaBonal University in Uzbekistan, have published relevant documents. No policies or recommendaBons regarding the use of GenAI are found on the official websites of art universiBes in the region.To assess insBtuBonal readiness and policies regarding GenAI across different regions, we applied the theoreBcal framework proposed by Lim et al. [11], which encompasses seven dimensions of strategic planning. Building on this framework, we constructed a structured analyBcal matrix covering each dimension (e.g., vision and narraBve, curriculum integraBon, technology-centric support, human-centric support, stakeholder engagement), and mapped the content of insBtuBonal policies to these categories. Three researchers independently described the policies of each university across the seven dimensions of the Lim et al. framework. Their individual descripBons were then compared and consolidated into a unified account through discussion, which helped to ensure consistency of interpretaBon. While this approach provided a structured basis for cross-regional comparison, we acknowledge certain limitaBons: in several cases, insBtuBons did not provide comprehensive or publicly accessible documentaBon, and therefore only parBal evidence could be included, which may underrepresent the actual extent of insBtuBonal readiness. Separately, a raBng system inspired by the methodology of [7] was developed to evaluate the leniency of university policies. Table 1 presents the universiBes from US and Europe included in the analysis, along with their leniency raBngs based on a 5-point Likert scale. UniversiBes from Central Asia are excluded as most did not have GenAI policies yet. Three authors independently evaluated the policies aWer agreeing on raBng criteria. Final raBngs were determined by majority voBng. Nevertheless, we acknowledge the potenBal influence of subjecBve factors on the assessment results, which is primarily due to implicit ambiguiBes in the policy formulaBons.Most universiBes showed a moderate degree of leniency (raBngs of '3' or '4') to the integraBon of GenAI into the educaBonal process and scienBfic research, while all educaBonal insBtuBons recognize the importance of using new technologies and the need to adapt to modern realiBes. For instance, The University of Chicago's policy received a '3' for educaBon because the university allows GenAI in selected tasks, from brainstorming ideas to clarifying complex concepts, but also sets limits on its use in some academic work. The University of Edinburgh was rated '4' as they permit the use of GenAI flexibly provided it is disclosed. Only two universiBes received a raBng of '2' for educaBon: the University of Amsterdam and Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, because they allow only limited use for narrowly defined purposes.Takeaway: These iniBal observaBons highlight a fundamental gap: while many insBtuBons recognize the transformaBve potenBal of GenAI, policy responses remain largely reacBve and fragmented, lacking a unified framework to support both educaBonal and research pracBces.Table 1. Leniency raDngs on a 5-pt Likert scale for universiDes in USA and Europe, where "1" = "Extremel
Related publications
- Lost in Speech: Trilingual Spoken Hallucination Detection Across Audio and Transcripts2026 · Citations: 1 · Same author: Meruyert Aristombayeva
- TRILOGUE: A Trilingual Spoken Dialogue Fact-Checking Benchmark with Evidence and Paired AudioFindings of the Association for Computational Linguistics: EMNLP · 2026 · Same author: Meruyert Aristombayeva
- Optimizing the Mean Shift Algorithm for Efficient ClusteringMathematics · 2025 · Citations: 4 · Same author: Meruyert Aristombayeva
- Generative AI use, self-regulation, and Neuro-AI Pedagogical competence in higher education: a comparative study of undergraduate and graduate students in UzbekistanFrontiers in Education · 2026 · Citations: 2 · Shared topic: Artificial Intelligence in Education
